Metal vs Asphalt Roof Cost Comparison Calculator
Compare the installed cost, lifespan and cost per year of a metal roof versus an asphalt shingle roof for your home.
Compare Your Options And Get Clear Answers
Compare the installed cost, lifespan and cost per year of a metal roof versus an asphalt shingle roof for your home.
Metal vs Asphalt Roof Cost Comparison Estimator
Enter your numbers below for an instant estimate.
How It Works
Key concepts behind this calculator
Installed Cost
Squares Γ installed cost per square.
Replacements
Years of ownership Γ· lifespan, rounded up.
Lifetime Cost
Replacement costs plus maintenance minus energy savings.
Use As A Guide
Results are estimates based on your inputs. Check real quotes, rates and professional advice before deciding.
Roof Type Guide
Typical installed costs and lifespans.
| Roof Type | Cost per Square | Lifespan | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3-tab asphalt | $300 β $450 | 15 β 20 years | Cheapest |
| Architectural asphalt | $400 β $600 | 20 β 30 years | Most common |
| Standing seam metal | $800 β $1,500 | 40 β 70 years | Premium |
| Metal shingle | $600 β $1,000 | 40 β 60 years | Looks like shingles |
| Rule of Thumb | Stay 15+ years β metal | Short stay β asphalt | Check insurance discount |
Metal vs Asphalt Calculator FAQ
Answers to common questions about this calculator.
It often is if you stay long enough, because it lasts two to three times longer and needs less maintenance.
With proper decking and insulation they are no louder than other roofs.
100 square feet of roof area.
No. They are example ranges. Get local quotes.