Instantly compare a taxable monthly car allowance against HMRC approved mileage allowance, based on your business miles, employer mileage rate, and tax band. See which option leaves you better off.
Compare Your Car Options
Enter your business mileage, allowance, and tax details below to see an instant, itemised comparison of a taxable car allowance versus claiming HMRC approved mileage allowance.
Allowance vs Mileage Estimator
Fill in your details to see your estimated annual comparison
Miles driven for work, not including your commute
Employer’s per-mile rate paid on top of the allowance (often lower than the HMRC rate)
Used to estimate tax on the allowance and mileage tax relief
Estimated Annual Comparison
Breakdown based on your mileage, allowance, and tax rate
Making Sense of the Car Allowance vs Mileage Calculator Full Walkthrough
What this calculator does
Think of the Car Allowance vs Mileage Calculator as a fast second opinion. You can run your own sums, enter the same details here, and see straight away whether car allowance vs mileage lines up with what you expected.
Who it helps
Fleet managers, weekend mechanics and used-car shoppers often turn to calculators like this one. Matching your own situation to the inputs takes only a moment, and you can repeat the process whenever your circumstances change. It often comes into play when planning a long road trip, working out fuel use for a new route and checking a repair quote, because a reliable figure for car allowance vs mileage prevents costly second-guessing.
Getting accurate results
For the most accurate result, gather your figures before you open the calculator. Double-check each value, keep your units consistent, and make a point to revisit the numbers after each service. Then enter the details, review the output, and adjust one input at a time to see how sensitive car allowance vs mileage is to each change.
Mistakes to avoid
When results seem off, the cause is frequently rounding fuel prices too early or comparing vehicles with different specifications. Re-reading your inputs line by line is the quickest way to find and fix either one.
Reading your result
Results are most useful when you understand what drives them. Experiment with mileage and allowance in turn, and you will quickly see which one matters most for car allowance vs mileage. We update our tools regularly, so check back for improvements to car allowance vs mileage and related automotive calculators. Bookmark this page so the Car Allowance vs Mileage Calculator is always one tap away when you need it again. Because the calculation runs instantly in your browser, you can test as many scenarios as you like without any limit.
A note on accuracy
Remember that the Car Allowance vs Mileage Calculator works with the information you supply. For anything critical, double-check the details independently or ask someone qualified to review your figures.
HMRC Approved Mileage Rates
These are the current HMRC Approved Mileage Allowance Payment (AMAP) rates. You can be paid up to these amounts tax-free, or claim relief on the shortfall if your employer pays less.
| Vehicle Type | First 10,000 Miles | Over 10,000 Miles | Passenger Supplement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Car or Van | 45p per mile | 25p per mile | +5p per mile |
| Motorcycle | 24p per mile | 24p per mile | N/A |
| Bicycle | 20p per mile | 20p per mile | N/A |
Car Allowance vs Mileage FAQ
Everything you need to know about comparing a car allowance with mileage allowance, and how to make sure you’re not missing out on tax relief.
Yes. A car allowance is paid through payroll as part of your salary, so it is subject to Income Tax and National Insurance in the same way as your regular earnings. This is different from mileage payments, which can be paid tax-free up to HMRC’s approved rates.
For cars and vans, HMRC’s Approved Mileage Allowance Payment (AMAP) rate is 45 pence per mile for the first 10,000 business miles in a tax year, and 25 pence per mile after that. These rates are designed to cover fuel, wear and tear, insurance, and other running costs.
Yes. If your employer pays you less than the HMRC approved mileage rate for business miles, you can claim tax relief on the shortfall directly from HMRC, regardless of whether you also receive a car allowance. Relief is given at your marginal tax rate, not as a full pound-for-pound refund.
It depends on how many business miles you drive. High-mileage drivers often come out ahead with mileage allowance because it is paid tax-free at HMRC rates, while low-mileage drivers may prefer a fixed car allowance for its predictability, even though it is taxed.
